Representations made on planning applications following the meeting of the Planning Committee held on 4 July 2023:
SDNP/23/02109/FUL: 205 High Street: Section 73A Retrospective application for front fascia restored and redesigned, redirection of flue extract at rear, erection of a rear timber single-storey extension, replacement of window at rear and an addition of another flue extract.
The Friends of Lewes object to this retrospective application, as the Society considers that the design of the front façade at this prominent location in the High Street, to be totally unacceptable within the Conservation Area. Furthermore, the Society is aware that this property has been highlighted in the current Lewes CAAMP and Article 4 Direction Review consultation document, as being an example of an unacceptable design solution within the Conservation Area.
SDNP/23/02186/HOUS: 50 Morris Road: Replacement of UPVC windows to front elevation with timber sash windows, addition of tile hanging to front bay window, painted detailing to gable end to front, repainting of front door, and replacement of concrete path to front with tiles.
The Friends of Lewes support and welcome this proposal, as it will result in a significant improvement to the streetscape in Morris Road, and the Society commends the initiative of the owners. However, in order to ensure the success of the proposal, it would be useful to have details of the proposed windows to be submitted.
SDNP/23/02288/LIS: 137 High Street: Refurbishment of 40no. windows to match existing.
The Friends of Lewes support the replacement of the windows in this listed building and appreciates the amount of work involved, including improvements to the draught proving. However, the Society would like to suggest that conservation grade double glazing should be considered if at all possible, in order to decrease heat loss from the building.
SDNP/23/02298/LIS: The White Hart Hotel 55 High Street: Internal alterations including the relocation of bar and reception, introduction of guest bedrooms on lower ground floor, demolition and replacement of conservatory with associated works.
The Friends of Lewes support and welcome these proposed works, as the Society considers that it will revitalise an important historic building in the centre of Lewes. As such, the improved hotel will act as a significant amenity for both residents and visitors.
SDNP/23/02456/HOUS: 4 St Nicholas Lane: Section 73a retrospective application for the erection of a single storey rear extension and installation of decking and cladding to the dormer.
The Friends of Lewes object to the use of UVPC cladding to the rear dormer and notes that UVPC has also been used in the fenestration to the rear. As such, the Society considers to use of UVPC to be unacceptable within the Conservation Area, even if the material cannot be seen from St Nicholas Lane.
SDNP/23/02515/CND: Lewes New School Talbot Terrace: Removal of conditions 3 (fitting of automated black-out blinds) and 8 (use of outdoor space only to take place between 9am and 5pm every day) related to Planning Approval SDNP/22/04944/FUL.
The Friends of Lewes object to the removal of either of these conditions. Condition 3, the fitting of automated black-out blinds, will limit the amount of light emitted from the building in accordance with the current “Dark Skies Policy”. Condition 8, the use of the outdoor space only to take place between 9am and 5pm every day, will limit the amount of noise and intrusion within the neighbourhood outside school hours.
SDNP/23/02589/HOUS: 6 Park Road: Construction of roof dormer and installation of 1no roof light.
The Friends of Lewes appreciate that the proposed roof dormer is effectively to the rear of the Park Road frontage and located within a large garden. However, the Society considers the proposal to be a little ‘clumsy’ and considers that the proposed shower might be able to be accommodated within the existing roof space, or within the area that appears to be designated for storage or a dressing room. The Society also notes that there is no ‘western elevation’ illustrating the proposed Velux roof light.
SDNP/23/02568/FUL: Pannetts Building Railway Lane: Extensions and alterations to provide retail use at ground floor and conversion of other areas to provide 2 x 3 bed flats, 4 x 2 bed flats and 1 x 3 duplex flat with external terrace and alteration to existing roof.
The Friends of Lewes object to this proposal as it raises a number of concerns that the Society considers need to be addressed further, as follows:-
- Although the Society welcomes the retention of commercial uses on the ground floor and on part of the first floor, there is a total lack of any storage space for bicycles, rubbish bins and recycling bins for any of the future occupants, which is considered to be totally unacceptable at this busy location.
- The significant increase in height in order to accommodate a single bedroomed flat on the fourth floor is considered to be unacceptable and the roof terrace facing the river would have an adverse visual impact on the roofline of this east elevation.
- The additional structure to accommodate the proposed lift on the south elevation is not considered to be well detailed, and indeed future occupants of the third and fourth floors would still be required to use internal staircases.
- As an alternative approach, it is suggested that consideration be given to providing a lift structure in the centre of the Railway Lane elevation that would provide access to all floors and as such act as a design feature on the former warehouse building.
SDNP/23/02569/LIS: 140 High Street: Hard and soft landscaping to rear.
The Friends of Lewes object to this proposed landscaping scheme to the rear of 140 High Street, as the Society considers that a more permeable solution, that would improve any surface water run-off, would be a more appropriate landscaping solution at this location.
The Committee examined the following applications and had no observations to make:
| SDNP/23/01070/HOUS: 33 Spences Lane |
Erection of a single storey rear extension. |
| SDNP/23/01515/LDE: 119A South Street |
Change of use from office/storage to residential for an ancillary building. |
| SDNP/23/02002/HOUS: 9 Talbot Terrace |
Addition of rear dormer, demolition of existing rear extension, alterations to rear fenestration, and addition of rooflights to front and rear. |
| SDNP/23/02271/HOUS: 3 Montacute Road |
Erection of a single-storey rear extension and internal remodelling on ground floor. |
